The Waterfall That's In Your Basement: Home Seller Liability and Buyer Remedies for Basement Water Damage

 With the change in seasons, snow melt and the onset of spring rain, some home buyers, who had recently purchased their property during the winter months, have come to discover to their surprise that their basement leaks or worse, floods. Nothing is more disappointing, frustrating and disruptive as having a basement leak or flood, especially when the buyer relied upon a seller’s statements concerning a home’s condition and a home inspection. They relied upon their seller’s representations that the seller had no knowledge of basement water problems. In almost all cases, had the buyers known of existing water problems, they would not have written an offer on their home.

 With very few exceptions, Michigan real estate law requires that a home seller must in good faith, provide a complete disclosure of their home’s condition to prospective purchasers prior to selling the property. Sellers are not liable for errors in the disclosure statement which are not within their personal knowledge. But when they know of a current water problem or had a former water issue, they had better disclose this fact to their buyer. Yet, there still are sellers who think they can get away with misleading their buyer and it's this misguided attitude that continues to contribute to my job security.

Seller Misrepresentation

 In Michigan, a seller may be legally and financially culpable to a buyer for making statements contained in the disclosure form that they knew or should have known are inaccurate. Sellers are committing “misrepresentation,” when the seller had personal knowledge of the problem, but failed to exercise "good faith", by not disclosing that knowledge. In cases of water damage that allege a seller’s misrepresentation, Michigan courts look at whether or not a “reasonable fact finder” could determine if the seller knew about a leak, yet allowed the transaction to move forward without disclosing the water problem to the buyer.

Seller Fraud on the Buyer

 When a seller fails to disclose known water leaks and then tries to conceal the damage, they are committing fraud. It is deceitful and if the seller is found culpable, they will be responsible for triple the damages. An example of knowingly concealing water damage is when a seller installs new paneling or drywall over a water damaged area so as to prevent the buyer or their inspector from discovering the water problem.

Buyer’s Remedies Against the Seller

Rescission

 In both instances where a seller has been found to misrepresent or intentionally mislead the seller by hiding or concealing water damage, Michigan courts allow a buyer to rescind or cancel the entire purchase transaction. This can come months after the buyer has moved into their home. The purchaser of the home is permitted to transfer the property to the seller, and the seller must return the purchase price, plus interest.

Triple Damages

 Buyers don’t have to actually rescind the transaction. They can sue for their money damages if they elect to remain in their home. Damages can include the cost to remove the material that concealed an offending leak, as well as the costs for repairs and restoration needed to stop the leak in the future. In cases of fraud, sellers are responsible for triple the damages. For example, a $10,000 problem can cost a deceitful home seller $30,000.

Conclusion

 Real estate transactions are serious business and the related home disclosure requirements should not be taken lightly. If a seller is uncertain as to whether they should disclose a known defect in the home that cannot be observed in plain sight, always remember that it’s best to disclose. A competent real estate professional can address the defect in the sales price. The alternative choice to hide a known defect from a home buyer will be far more costly later. When in doubt, or if you are having problems with the condition of your home after the home sale, consult with a real estate attorney. Effective April 15, 2017, claim your free book: What's Keeping You Up At Night? An Attorney's Practical Approach to Resolve Real Estate Nightmares at www.provenresource.com/book4U .